DBプロジェクトをAzureサーバーと比較するとSSDTスキーマ比較が失敗する

Question

エンタープライズDBを構築したSQLデータベースプロジェクトがあります。 SSDTのスキーマ比較ツールを使用して、内部およびAWSがホストするSQLサーバーに数回デプロイされています。

SQL Ent 2012 sp2を実行しているAzure Hosted Win 2012 Serverに投稿するときの問題。 「比較が完了しました。差異は検出されませんでした」というメッセージが表示されます。

Enterprise Managerを開いてスキーマをSQLプロジェクトと比較し、違いがあることがわかるので、これは間違っていることを知っています。

2014年のリリースがどのようにツールを壊したかについて話している記事をいくつか見つけましたが、それらはバージョンの違いでした。

[はい、これをGoogleで行いました。私がそうすることを忘れることで悪名高いので、述べます。 ] https://www.google.com/webhp?ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8#q=ssdt+data+compare+fail+to+detect+difference&start=1

私がチェックした他のことには、私のDBアカウントが無制限のアクセスを持っていることを確認することが含まれます。管理コンソールに接続できます。ローカルプログラムと接続できます。

問題があったことの最後の確認：

1. 作成したSPこれは、1の単一の戻り値を持っています。
   1. テストのために何も返されない可能性があります。
2. SPを作成した後、すべてのインスタンスでスキーマ比較を実行し、Azureサーバー以外のすべてで差異が示されました。

更新

これが明示的にサーバーにあることを確認しました。2つの異なるコンピューター上の2人の異なるユーザーが同じ正確な問題を抱えているからです。

Answer 1

TL; DR

Visual Studioが実行しているクエリがブロックされ、クエリがタイムアウトします。

---

私はこれを私たちの状況のた​​めにうまく管理することができました：ブロックのためにタイムアウトしました！

アプリケーション名にフィルターを使用してプロファイラートレースを実行しMicrosoft SQL Serverデータツール、スキーマ比較Visual Studioスキーマ比較イベントをキャプチャしました。

VSが比較が完了したと主張するとき、特定のクエリに到達して停止します。

問題のクエリのバッチは次のとおりです。

_select object_id as id, 
    null as id2,
    case
        when [type] != 'D ' then [type]
        when parent_object_id != 0 then 'D '
        else 'LD' 
    end as [type],
    schema_name(schema_id) as name1,
    name as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.objects
where 
    type != 'S'
    and is_ms_shipped != 1

union

select principal_id as id, 
    null as id2,
    type, 
    name as name1, 
    null as name2, 
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.database_principals

union

select Assembly_id as id, 
    null as id2,
    'CLR' as type, 
    name as name1, 
    null as name2, 
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.assemblies
where
    is_user_defined =1

union

select schema_id as id, 
    null as id2,
    'SCH' as type, 
    name as name1, 
    null as name2, 
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    null as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.schemas

union

select user_type_id as id, 
    null as id2,
    case
        when is_Assembly_type = 1 then 'UDT'
        when is_table_type = 1 then 'TT'
        else 'UDDT'
    end as [type],
    schema_name(schema_id) as name1,
    name as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    binary_checksum(system_type_id, schema_id, max_length, precision, scale, is_nullable, is_Assembly_type, default_object_id, rule_object_id) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.types
where
    is_user_defined = 1

union

select idx.object_id as id,
    idx.index_id as id2,
    case
        when idx.type = 3 then 'XIX'
        when idx.type = 4 then 'SIX'
        when idx.type = 6 then 'CIX'
        else 'IDX' 
    end as [type],
    schema_name(tab.schema_id) as name,
    tab.name as name2,
    idx.name as name3,
    null as a1,
    binary_checksum(is_unique, data_space_id, ignore_dup_key, is_primary_key, is_unique_constraint, fill_factor, is_padded, is_disabled, allow_row_locks, allow_page_locks) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.indexes idx 
    inner join sys.tables tab on idx.object_id = tab.object_id
where 
    idx.is_primary_key = 0
    and idx.name is not null
    and idx.is_unique_constraint = 0
    and idx.is_hypothetical = 0

union

select stat.object_id as id,
    stat.stats_id as id2,
    'STAT' as [type],
    schema_name(tab.schema_id) as name,
    tab.name as name2,
    stat.name as name3,
    null as a1,
    no_recompute as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.stats stat
    inner join sys.tables tab on stat.object_id = tab.object_id
where 
    stat.user_created = 1

union

select xml_collection_id as id,
    null as id2,
    'XSC' as type,
    schema_name(schema_id),
    name as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod 
from sys.xml_schema_collections
where xml_collection_id > 1

union

select 
    object_id id,
    null id2,
    'DDT' as type,
    name,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod 
from sys.triggers
where
    parent_class = 0

union

select
    database_specification_id id,
    null as id2,
    'DAS' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.database_audit_specifications

union

select 
    certificate_id id,
    null as id2,
    'CERT' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    binary_checksum(pvt_key_encryption_type, thumbprint) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.certificates

union

select
    asymmetric_key_id id,
    null as id2,
    'ASMK' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    null as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.asymmetric_keys

union

select
    symmetric_key_id id,
    null as id2,
    case
        when name = N'##MS_DatabaseMasterKey##' then 'MK'
        else 'SYMK'
    end as type,
    case
        when name = N'##MS_DatabaseMasterKey##' then null
        else name
    end as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.symmetric_keys
where
    name = N'##MS_DatabaseMasterKey##'
    or name not like N'##%'

union

select
    fulltext_catalog_id id,
    null as id2,
    'FTC' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    binary_checksum(is_default, is_accent_sensitivity_on) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.fulltext_catalogs

union

select
    ft.object_id id,
    ft.unique_index_id as id2,
    'FTI' as type,
    schema_name(o.schema_id) as name1,
    o.name as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    binary_checksum(is_enabled, change_tracking_state) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.fulltext_indexes ft
inner join sys.objects o on ft.object_id = o.object_id

union

select
    stoplist_id id,
    null as id2,
    'FTSL' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.fulltext_stoplists

union

select
    data_space_id id,
    null as id2,
    [type] as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    is_default as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.data_spaces

union

select
    function_id id,
    null as id2,
    'PF' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.partition_functions

union

select
    file_id id,
    null as id2,
    'FILE' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    binary_checksum(type, data_space_id, physical_name, state, growth, is_read_only, is_sparse, is_percent_growth) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.database_files


union

select
    message_type_id id,
    null as id2,
    'MT' as [type],
    name collate database_default as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    binary_checksum(validation, xml_collection_id) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.service_message_types

union

select
    service_contract_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SC' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    null as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.service_contracts

union

select
    service_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SERVICE' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    binary_checksum(service_queue_id) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.services

union

select
    route_id id,
    null as id2,
    'ROUTE' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    binary_checksum(remote_service_name, broker_instance, lifetime, address, mirror_address) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.routes

union

select
    remote_service_binding_id id,
    null as id2,
    'RSB' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    principal_id as a1,
    binary_checksum(service_contract_id, remote_principal_id, is_anonymous_on) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.remote_service_bindings

union

select 
    object_id id,
    null as id2,
    'DEN' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.event_notifications

union

select
    priority_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SBP' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    binary_checksum(service_contract_id, local_service_id, remote_service_name, priority) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.conversation_priorities


union

select
    principal_id id,
    null as id2,
    'LOG' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.server_principals
where
    type != 'R'

union

select
    audit_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SAD' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.server_audits

union

select
    credential_id id,
    null as id2,
    'CRD' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.credentials


union

select
    msg.message_id id,
    msg.language_id as id2,
    'SEM' as type,
    cast(msg.message_id as sysname) as name1,
    lang.alias collate database_default as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    binary_checksum(msg.severity, msg.is_event_logged, msg.text) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.messages msg inner join sys.syslanguages lang on (msg.language_id = lang.lcid)
where
    msg.message_id > 50000

union

select 
    base.endpoint_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SEP' as type,
    base.name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    base.principal_id as a1,
    binary_checksum(*) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.endpoints base  
    left outer join sys.http_endpoints http on (base.endpoint_id = http.endpoint_id)
    left outer join sys.service_broker_endpoints sb on (base.endpoint_id = sb.endpoint_id)
    left outer join sys.soap_endpoints soap on (base.endpoint_id = soap.endpoint_id)
    left outer join sys.tcp_endpoints tcp on (base.endpoint_id = tcp.endpoint_id)
    left outer join sys.database_mirroring_endpoints mirror on (base.endpoint_id = mirror.endpoint_id)

union

select 
    server_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SLS' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.servers

union

select 
    logins.server_id id,
    logins.local_principal_id as id2,
    'SLL' as type,
    srvs.name as name1,
    lp.name as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    logins.modify_date as mod
from sys.linked_logins logins 
    inner join sys.servers srvs on (logins.server_id = srvs.server_id)
    left join sys.server_principals lp on (logins.local_principal_id = lp.principal_id)

union

select 
    object_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SST' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.server_triggers
where
    is_ms_shipped = 0

union

select 
    server_specification_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SAS' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    modify_date as mod
from sys.server_audit_specifications

union

select 
    event_session_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SES' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    null as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.server_event_sessions

union

select 
    provider_id id,
    null as id2,
    'SCP' as type,
    name as name1,
    null as name2,
    null as name3,
    null as a1,
    binary_checksum(guid, version, dll_path, is_enabled) as v1,
    null as mod
from sys.cryptographic_providers


select 
    cast(32 as tinyint) as class,
    'SES' as type,
    event_session_id as majorid,
    binary_checksum(event_id, name, package, module) as minorid,
    name as name,
    null as id1,
    null as id2
from sys.server_event_session_actions

union

select 
    cast(32 as tinyint) as class,
    'SES' as type,
    event_session_id as majorid,
    event_id as minorid,
    name as name,
    binary_checksum(predicate) as id1,
    null as id2
from sys.server_event_session_events

union

select 
    cast(32 as tinyint) as class,
    'SES' as type,
    event_session_id as majorid,
    object_id as minorid,
    name as name,
    binary_checksum(value) as id1,
    null as id2
from sys.server_event_session_fields

union

select 
    cast(32 as tinyint) as class,
    'SES' as type,
    event_session_id as majorid,
    event_id as minorid,
    name as name,
    null as id1,
    null as id2
from sys.server_event_session_events


union

select 
    perms.class as class,
    objectpropertyex(perms.major_id, 'BaseType') as type,
    perms.major_id as majorid,
    perms.minor_id as minorid,
    perms.type + perms.state collate database_default as name,
    perms.grantee_principal_id as id1,
    perms.grantor_principal_id as id2
from sys.database_permissions perms
where
    perms.major_id >= 0

union

select 
    props.class as class,
    case 
        when objs.parent_object_id > 0 then objectpropertyex(objs.parent_object_id, 'BaseType') 
        else objectpropertyex(props.major_id, 'BaseType') 
    end as type,
    case
        when objs.parent_object_id > 0 then objs.parent_object_id
        else props.major_id
    end as majorid,
    props.minor_id as minorid,
    props.name as name,
    binary_checksum(props.value) as id1,
    null as id2
from sys.extended_properties props left outer join sys.objects objs on props.major_id = objs.object_id

union

select 
    cast(4 as tinyint) as class,
    'R' as type,
    roles.role_principal_id as majorid,
    roles.member_principal_id as minorid,
    'drm' as name,
    null as id1,
    null as id2
from sys.database_role_members roles 

union

select 
    cast(6 as tinyint) as class,
    'TT' as type,
    tt.user_type_id as majorid,
    cols.column_id as minorid, 
    cols.name as name,
    binary_checksum(cols.user_type_id, cols.max_length, cols.precision, cols.scale, 
        cols.collation_name, cols.is_nullable, cols.is_ansi_padded, cols.is_rowguidcol, cols.is_identity, 
        cols.is_computed, cols.is_xml_document, cols.xml_collection_id, cols.default_object_id, cols.rule_object_id) as id1,
    null as id2
from sys.table_types tt inner join sys.columns cols on (tt.type_table_object_id = cols.object_id)


select 
    cols.object_id as tableid,
    cols.column_id as columnid, 
    binary_checksum(cols.name) as checksum
from sys.tables tabs 
    inner join sys.columns cols  on (tabs.object_id = cols.object_id)
    inner join sys.index_columns idx_cols on (idx_cols.object_id = tabs.object_id and idx_cols.column_id = cols.column_id)
where
    tabs.is_ms_shipped = 0

union

select 
    object_id as tableid,
    column_id as columnid, 
    binary_checksum(type_column_id, language_id) as checksum
from sys.fulltext_index_columns
_

SSMSでクエリを実行しても、問題のサーバーでの実行は完了しませんが、他のすべての環境では1秒もかかりません。

だから私はそれを引き離し始め、次の3つのシステムビューから読み取っているクエリに問題があることがわかりました。

• _sys.server_event_session_actions_
• _sys.server_event_session_events_
• _sys.server_event_session_fields_

これらのシステムビューの最初のビューには28個のレコードしか含まれていませんでしたが（Count(*)を実行すると見つかりました）、_(NOLOCK)_ヒ​​ントを使用しない限りデータは返されません...[b] locking問題！

ブロッキングチェーンの先頭を見つけるのは簡単でしたが、拡張イベントセッションであるため、強制終了することはできませんでした。この問題の修正はここにあります： https://support.Microsoft.com/en-gb/kb/251196

しかし、うまくいけば、あなたの場合には、チェーンの頭をうまく殺して、物事を通常に戻すことができます！

---

EDIT：影響を受けるSQL Serverの実行可能なメンテナンスウィンドウがあり、再起動によりSPIDがクリアされ、比較が再び機能するようになりました！

また、今後の読者に役立つ可能性があるブロッキングチェーンの先頭を見つけるために私が書いた簡単なスクリプトを次に示します。 http://gvee.co.uk/files/sql/admin.blocking_chains.sql

_IF Object_ID('admin.blocking_chains', 'V') IS NULL
  BEGIN
    EXEC ('CREATE VIEW admin.blocking_chains AS SELECT NULL As buffer;');
  END
;
GO

ALTER VIEW admin.blocking_chains
  AS
WITH processes AS (
  SELECT s.spid
       , s.blocked As blocking_spid
       , DB_Name(s.dbid) As database_name
       , s.program_name
       , Cast(x.text As varchar(Max)) As definition
       , hostname As Host_name
       , loginame As login_name
       , nt_domain
       , nt_username
  FROM   sys.sysprocesses (NOLOCK) As s
   CROSS
    APPLY sys.dm_exec_sql_text(s.sql_handle) As x
  WHERE s.spid > 50
)
, blocking (spid, blocking_spid, blocking_statement, sequence, level, database_name) AS (
  SELECT s.spid
       , s.blocking_spid
       , s.definition
       , Row_Number() OVER (ORDER BY s.spid) As sequence
       , 0 As level
       , s.database_name
  FROM   processes As s
   INNER
    JOIN processes As s1
      ON s1.blocking_spid = s.spid
  WHERE  s.blocking_spid = 0

    UNION ALL

      SELECT r.spid
           , r.blocking_spid
           , r.definition
           , d.sequence
           , d.level + 1
           , r.database_name
      FROM   processes As r
       INNER
        JOIN blocking As d
          ON d.spid = r.blocking_spid
      WHERE  r.blocking_spid > 0
)
, results AS (
  SELECT blocking_spid
       , spid
       , blocking_statement
       , level
       , Min(sequence) As sequence
       , Min(database_name) As database_name
  FROM   blocking
  GROUP
      BY blocking_spid
       , spid
       , blocking_statement
       , level
)
SELECT Cast(CASE WHEN results.blocking_spid = 0 THEN 1 ELSE 0 END As bit) As is_head_of_chain
     , results.sequence
     , results.level
     , results.database_name
     , results.spid
     , results.blocking_spid
     , results.blocking_statement
     , processes.Host_name
     , processes.program_name
     , processes.login_name
     , processes.nt_domain
     , processes.nt_username
     , Right('0000' + Cast(results.sequence As varchar(11)), 5) + '-' + Right('0000' + Cast(results.level As varchar(11)), 5) As sort_order
FROM   results
 LEFT
  JOIN processes
    ON processes.spid = results.spid
;
_

Answer 2

Visual Studio、SSMSを閉じ、ウィンドウサービスのコントロールパネルを介してSQL Serverサービスを停止して再起動すると、問題が発生しました。既存のセッションを強制終了したためです。